
What Makes a Brand Experience Worth Remembering?
What Makes a Brand Experience Worth Remembering?
A hotel upgrade you weren't expecting. A store associate who did something genuinely thoughtful. An unexpected moment at an event that ended up being your favorite part.
Some brand experiences stay with us long after they're over, and often, it's the unplanned moments we remember most.
Marketers have a name for this: surprise and delight. The idea is simple enough. Do something unexpected that makes a customer's experience better.
But there's an interesting challenge behind it. Brands spend months planning experiences, mapping customer journeys, and carefully considering every interaction. How do you deliberately create something that's supposed to feel spontaneous?
And at what point does a surprise stop feeling special and start feeling like another marketing tactic?
The Best Surprises Aren't Always the Biggest
When brands think about surprise and delight, it's easy to jump to the grand gestures: elaborate giveaways, celebrity appearances, exclusive merchandise, or experiences designed to generate social media attention.
Those moments can certainly be memorable. But the size of the gesture isn't always what determines its impact.
Consider Chewy, the online pet retailer known for sending flowers, handwritten notes, and even commissioned pet portraits to customers who have lost a pet. These gestures have earned the brand considerable attention over the years, often because customers choose to share their experiences publicly.
What's interesting about Chewy's approach is that the surprise is connected to a very specific moment in the customer's life. It isn't a generic reward for spending a certain amount or reaching a membership milestone.
The gesture feels meaningful because of when it happens and what it acknowledges.
There's an important lesson here for marketers. A memorable experience doesn't necessarily require a bigger budget. It requires an understanding of the moment and the judgment to respond appropriately.
Sometimes that means doing something extraordinary. Other times, it means noticing an opportunity that would be easy to overlook.
You Can Plan the Experience Without Scripting Every Moment
Most brand experiences are carefully orchestrated, and for good reason.
Retail environments need to function. Events require logistics, staffing, and coordination. Customer interactions need to reflect the brand and meet certain standards.
But when every moment is scripted, there's little room to respond to what actually happens.
The hospitality industry offers an interesting example of how brands approach this challenge.
The Ritz-Carlton is known for giving employees discretion to resolve guest issues and create memorable experiences without seeking approval for every decision. Its widely discussed employee empowerment practices recognize that the person interacting directly with a guest may be best positioned to understand what would make that particular experience better.
The point isn't that every business should adopt the same policies or spending allowances.
It's that memorable experiences often depend on decisions made in the moment.
An associate might recognize that a customer is celebrating something. An event employee might find an unexpected way to involve a guest. A team member might notice a small frustration and resolve it before the customer has to ask.
Brands can establish the environment, train their teams, and provide the resources. But allowing people some freedom to respond to individual situations can make an experience feel more natural.
That flexibility is difficult to replicate through a rigid script.
When Surprise & Delight Becomes a Gimmick
There's a difference between creating a moment for a customer and creating a moment for a camera.
Brands understandably want their experiences to be shared. A memorable activation can generate attention far beyond the people who attend it, and unexpected moments can make compelling social content.
But when the primary goal becomes getting a reaction, the experience can start to feel manufactured.
Think about the difference between receiving an unexpected gift and being told you can receive a gift if you post a video, tag three friends, download an app, and provide your email address.
The second experience might still be an effective promotion. But the surprise has largely disappeared.
The same is true of experiences advertised as exclusive but offered to everyone, or elaborate activations that look impressive online but aren't particularly enjoyable for the people attending.
The question brands should ask is whether the experience would still be worthwhile if nobody posted about it.
Would the customer enjoy it? Would it improve their day? Would it give them a reason to remember the brand?
If the answer is yes, the social sharing becomes a potential benefit rather than the entire purpose.
Leave Room for the Unexpected
For marketers planning retail experiences, events, and activations, the goal shouldn't be to manufacture a perfect reaction from every customer.
A better approach is to create opportunities for something memorable to happen.
That might mean building interactive elements into an activation rather than having every visitor follow the same path. It could mean giving staff the flexibility to offer an unexpected perk or creating moments where customers can explore, participate, and discover something on their own.
It also means paying attention to how people actually respond.
An activation might be designed around one particular feature, only for attendees to become far more interested in something else. A spontaneous interaction might turn out to be the highlight of someone's visit.
Those observations are valuable. They can reveal what people genuinely enjoy, rather than what a brand assumed they would enjoy during the planning process.
Of course, none of this means abandoning structure. The logistics, service, and overall experience still need to work. A surprise won't make up for a frustrating event or a poorly run store.
But within that structure, there should be room for a little unpredictability.
Give People Something to Talk About
There's a reason brands continue investing in surprise and delight. An unexpected, positive experience gives people a story to tell.
For brands creating real-world experiences, that's an opportunity worth considering. At Sotto, we're interested in what happens when brands create more opportunities for customers to participate, discover, and engage in ways that feel natural to them.
Not every interaction needs to be extraordinary. In fact, if every moment is designed to be a surprise, the experience can quickly become exhausting.
Sometimes the smartest thing a brand can do is plan a great experience, give its people room to be creative, and leave a little space for something unexpected to happen.