Skip to content

What Is the Identity Gap, and Why Should Brands Care?

by Lindsey Buxman
Phygital Marketing
October 27, 2026

Contents

What Is the Identity Gap, and Why Should Brands Care?

‍

You can track what happened on your website at 2 a.m. last Tuesday. But do you know who walked into your store an hour ago?

‍

Online, brands can track browsing behavior, product interest, and engagement even when someone doesn't make a purchase. In physical stores, they can count visitors, but connecting those visits to individual customers is much more difficult.

‍

Retailers invest heavily in attracting customers through advertising, events, and in-store experiences. But there's one important question they often can't answer: Who are the people walking through their doors?

‍

That disconnect is the identity gap, and it represents a missed opportunity to turn store visits into lasting customer relationships.

‍

What Is the Identity Gap?

‍

The identity gap is the percentage of store visits a retailer can't connect to a known customer.

‍

For example, a retailer records 100,000 store visits and 40,000 transactions in a year. If half of those transactions are associated with known customers, that represents 20,000 identified transactions and an estimated identity gap of 80%.

‍

The distinction matters because a store visit doesn't necessarily lead to a purchase, and even a completed transaction doesn't always tell a retailer who the customer is.

‍

Why the Gap Exists

‍

For many retailers, customer identification happens primarily at checkout, when an associate asks for a loyalty number, email address, or phone number.

‍

But checkout is already a busy moment. Associates are focused on completing transactions, and customers are often ready to leave. More importantly, this approach overlooks everyone who visits without making a purchase.

‍

Consider someone who comes in to explore a new collection, asks a few questions, and leaves planning to return. The brand has an opportunity to build a relationship, but without a way to reconnect, that interaction ends when the shopper walks out.

‍

What Brands Are Missing

‍

Identifying customers isn't just about collecting more data. It's about making the marketing and engagement tools retailers already use more effective.

‍

Email campaigns, personalized offers, and loyalty programs depend on being able to recognize and reach customers. When store visitors remain unidentified, brands lose opportunities to continue conversations, learn about customer interests, and encourage return visits.

‍

Closing the gap doesn't mean asking every shopper for their information. It means creating opportunities for customers to voluntarily connect with a brand throughout their visit, whether they're exploring a product, participating in an event, or accessing an in-store experience.

‍

The interaction should offer something valuable to the customer, not feel like another requirement.

‍

Find Your Identity Gap

‍

At Sotto, we created the Identity Gap Calculator to help retailers estimate how much of their in-store traffic remains unidentified.

‍

Using annual store visits, transactions, and the percentage of transactions associated with known customers, the calculator estimates the identity gap. Retailers can also add their cost per new contact from paid channels and number of locations for additional context.

‍

The opportunity isn't just in the customers retailers are trying to attract. It's in the ones already walking through their doors.

‍

What's Your Identity Gap?

‍